Is our nation still wrestling with the question of monarchy versus republic? In this opinion piece, Don Wooten references Elizabeth Powel’s query and shows how “E pluribus unum” remains an elusive but vital goal for our collective identity.
Subscribe
Analysis and Opinions
Ancient Civilizations
Don Wooten: Monarchy or republic? How will we answer Elizabeth Powel’s question
Photo by The Quad City Times
Key Takeaways:
- The article debates whether a nation should be a monarchy or a republic.
- Elizabeth Powel’s question highlights the importance of civic engagement.
- “E pluribus unum” challenges us to realize true unity.
- References to ancient Greek conflicts and tragedies offer historical context.
- Published as an opinion piece by Don Wooten in The Quad City Times.
The Central Question
Monarchy or republic? This deceptively simple inquiry shapes Don Wooten’s latest opinion piece, drawing attention to how we organize our society and the guiding principles that hold it together. The question remains urgent for anyone who cares about the nature of governance.
Elizabeth Powel’s Inquiry
Elizabeth Powel has long been credited with sparking thoughtful controversy around the form of government America would choose. In invoking her name, Wooten underscores how the dilemma resonates today. Is our society delivering on the promises touted at its founding, or do old debates still linger?
The Motto “E Pluribus Unum”
“E pluribus unum,” famously emblazoned on the Great Seal of the United States, reminds us of unity’s centrality. As Wooten points out, it is “easy to say; hard to do.” Its inclusion in the national seal speaks to the aspiration of bringing diverse voices together under a shared vision—an ambition no less significant now than in centuries past.
Lessons from Ancient Greece
Historical references abound in the form of ancient Greek wars and cultural practices, such as the wars of the Delian League, the Peloponnesian War, and Greek tragedy. According to Wooten, these events offer perspective on how political power, civic duty, and collective identity have challenged societies since antiquity. Questions of who governs—and how—were as potent then as they are today.
Ties to the United States
Finally, Wooten connects the classical world’s lessons to our own founding documents and symbols. The Great Seal epitomizes this link, with the inscription “E pluribus unum” reflecting an enduring search for unity. Whether we consider ourselves a republic or fear sliding into monarchical tendencies, the heart of the issue remains: Can we unite under a common banner and fulfill the motto at the core of our identity?
