Pro Football Focus’s re-draft of the 2009 NFL draft class sees Philadelphia Eagles’ legendary running back LeSean McCoy soar into the top five picks, landing with the Cleveland Browns. This reimagined selection robs the Eagles of a key player who became a cornerstone of their offense.
Eagles’ legendary 2nd-round pick lands in the top five of a 2009 NFL re-draft by PFF

Key Takeaways:
- LeSean McCoy rises from a second-round pick to a top-five selection in PFF’s 2009 NFL re-draft.
- The Cleveland Browns select McCoy in this re-draft scenario.
- The Philadelphia Eagles lose out on acquiring their legendary running back.
- PFF re-evaluates the 2009 NFL draft based on players’ career performances.
A Reimagined Draft Order
Pro Football Focus (PFF) has revisited the 2009 NFL draft class, reshuffling the selections based on the players’ career achievements. This exercise brings about significant changes, impacting several teams, most notably the Philadelphia Eagles and the Cleveland Browns.
McCoy’s Meteoric Rise
LeSean McCoy, originally picked by the Eagles in the second round, makes a dramatic leap into the top five in PFF’s re-draft. Recognized as a legendary running back for Philadelphia, McCoy’s elevated status reflects the outstanding career he forged after his initial selection.
Eagles Lose Their Star Running Back
In this reimagined scenario, McCoy is claimed early by the Cleveland Browns. Philadelphia loses out on acquiring a player who would become a central figure in their offensive lineup. The absence of McCoy could have significantly altered the Eagles’ fortunes in the subsequent seasons.
A Game-Changer for the Browns
For the Browns, drafting McCoy in the top five presents a transformative opportunity. Securing a player of his caliber might have reshaped their offensive strategy and provided a much-needed boost to their performance during that era.
Reflecting on Draft Hindsight
PFF’s re-draft underscores the unpredictable nature of the NFL draft and the profound impact that hindsight can have on evaluating player potential. It highlights how different the league’s landscape might look if teams had foresight into the future successes of players like McCoy.
Your goal is to maintain the integrity of the original information while improving its presentation for TIME Magazine’s audience. Do not include any information that is not explicitly stated in or directly implied by the original news feed content.