In a twist of NFL history, Pro Football Focus’s 2012 redraft has the Indianapolis Colts selecting a different quarterback, redefining their team’s future.
Indianapolis Colts go a different direction in PFF’s 2012 NFL redraft

Key Takeaways:
- The Colts select a different quarterback in PFF’s 2012 NFL redraft.
- The article explores a hypothetical scenario in NFL drafting.
- Published on June 17, 2025, by Yahoo! News.
- It discusses the potential impact of alternate draft choices.
- The piece caters to sports enthusiasts interested in NFL narratives.
Reimagining the Colts’ 2012 Draft in PFF’s Redraft
The National Football League (NFL) draft is a pivotal event that shapes the future of franchises. In an intriguing exercise, Pro Football Focus (PFF) revisited the 2012 NFL Draft, offering a fresh perspective on how different choices could have altered the league’s landscape. Central to this reimagining is the Indianapolis Colts’ decision to select a different quarterback than the one they originally chose.
A New Direction at Quarterback
In PFF’s redraft, the Colts opt for an alternative talent to lead their team. This hypothetical selection marks a significant departure from their original decision, suggesting a new direction for the franchise’s offensive strategy. The choice of a quarterback is crucial, as it sets the tone for the team’s performance on the field.
Impact of the Hypothetical Selection
Selecting a different quarterback could have had profound implications for the Colts. The new pick might have brought a different skill set, leadership style, and dynamic to the team. This change prompts speculation about how the Colts’ seasons following 2012 might have unfolded under different leadership.
The Significance of Draft Choices
The exercise underscores the weight of decisions made during the draft. A single choice can reverberate through a team’s history, affecting coaching strategies, player development, and even fan engagement. By exploring alternate scenarios, PFF highlights the unpredictability and high stakes inherent in drafting.
Reflecting on NFL History
Hypothetical redrafts like PFF’s encourage fans and analysts to consider the myriad possibilities in NFL history. They offer a platform to discuss what might have been and to appreciate the complex factors that teams must weigh when making their selections.
Conclusion
The Indianapolis Colts’ reimagined choice in the 2012 NFL redraft serves as a compelling reminder of the delicate balance between decision and destiny in professional sports. While the past cannot be changed, exploring these scenarios provides valuable insights into the strategic elements that define the game.