Veteran referee Herb Dean has come under heavy criticism after his officiating at UFC Paris. Fans have gone so far as to call for his retirement, prompting a legendary referee to weigh in on the escalating debate.
Legendary referee weighs in on Herb Dean stoppage that had fans calling for his retirement after UFC Paris

Key Takeaways:
- Herb Dean’s officiating at UFC Paris is facing intense scrutiny.
- Fans are urging the veteran referee to retire from MMA.
- A “legendary referee” has stepped forward to offer commentary.
- The controversy highlights the significance of refereeing in the UFC.
- Bloody Elbow originally published these details.
The Controversy Over Dean’s Performance
Herb Dean, one of the UFC’s most prominent referees, found himself at the center of a storm following his work at UFC Paris. Fans flooded social media with harsh criticism about his handling of a stoppage, insisting it was time for him to retire from officiating.
Public Criticism and Calls for Retirement
Observers of the fight were quick to question Dean’s judgment, claiming he allowed unnecessary risk to the fighters. Some called on the long-serving official to step away from professional bouts altogether. Their calls underscore the importance of each referee’s split-second decisions in mixed martial arts, where one moment can define a fighter’s safety or future career.
A Legendary Referee Weighs In
In the midst of this whirlwind, a fellow iconic official in MMA—widely described as a “legendary referee”—offered his perspective on the event. The debate surrounding Dean’s conduct spotlighted the substantial role referees play in ensuring the integrity of the sport, showing that even a single contentious call can provoke heated discussion across the MMA community.
Broader Impact in MMA Officiating
Herb Dean’s reputation as a veteran referee has long been established. Nevertheless, the backlash from UFC Paris underscores how officiating controversies resonate with fans, fighters, and industry insiders alike. The scrutiny demonstrates both the intensity and the high stakes of MMA competition, where calls can be celebrated or deeply questioned, shaping the conversation around the sport.