A fiery first general election debate brought together Andrew Cuomo, Republican Curtis Sliwa, and Democrat Zohran Mamdani in a tense face-off. With Mamdani eager to defend the momentum that propelled him past Cuomo in the primary, the night saw heightened exchanges and few definitive blows.
Many swings, few knockout hits as Cuomo and Mamdani trade jabs in heated first NYC mayoral debate

Key Takeaways:
- This was the first general election debate for New York City’s mayoral race.
- Andrew Cuomo and Curtis Sliwa sought to slow Zohran Mamdani’s momentum.
- Zohran Mamdani, a 33-year-old democratic socialist, previously defeated Cuomo in the Democratic primary.
- The atmosphere remained highly contentious, with several attacks but no decisive winner.
- The article originally appeared in Bozeman Daily Chronicle on 2025-10-17 03:59:00.
A Contentious Start to the Race
New York City’s mayoral race opened with a heated first general election debate on Thursday evening, setting the stage for a lively season of political sparring. Former Governor Andrew Cuomo and Republican candidate Curtis Sliwa joined forces at times to confront the growing popularity of Democrat Zohran Mamdani, a 33-year-old democratic socialist who defeated Cuomo in the Democratic primary.
The Candidates
Andrew Cuomo, whose established political presence once made him a top contender, now faces a formidable challenge from Mamdani. Meanwhile, Curtis Sliwa, representing the Republican Party, offers a contrasting conservative viewpoint in this three-way showdown. All eyes, however, remain on Mamdani’s upward trajectory, especially after his upset victory over Cuomo.
The Heated Exchanges
During the debate, Cuomo and Sliwa both took opportunities to question Mamdani’s platform and record, hoping to diminish the momentum he has enjoyed in recent months. Mamdani, for his part, presented his democratic socialist vision for the city, emphasizing the same drive that propelled him to secure the Democratic nomination. Observers noted “many swings” aimed at rattling Mamdani’s campaign, but the evening produced few standout moments that could be called a knockout punch.
What Lies Ahead
With this first debate behind them, the candidates now look toward the critical weeks leading up to Election Day. The rhetorical clashes showcased the stark differences in ideology, strategy, and campaign style. As each contender refines their approach, voters will be watching closely to see if Mamdani’s surge can be sustained or if Cuomo and Sliwa’s combined attacks will alter the race’s trajectory.