No Such Thing as Presidential ‘Removal Power’ in Early America, Paper Finds

A new paper from Andrea Katz at Washington University in St. Louis challenges long-held assumptions about presidential authority. By examining early American perspectives, Katz reveals that the founders were far from unified in endorsing an unfettered executive power to fire officials.

Key Takeaways:

  • A newly released paper disputes the existence of an unequivocal presidential removal power in early America
  • Andrea Katz, an expert on constitutional law, focuses on whether the founding generation agreed on presidential authority to fire executive officials
  • The paper suggests American founders had diverse views on this crucial constitutional question
  • Katz’s research underscores the importance of historical context in modern debates
  • The findings may reshape how today’s policymakers and citizens perceive executive power

The Research

Andrea Katz, an associate professor of law at Washington University in St. Louis, has devoted her latest academic work to examining the historical roots of presidential authority. An expert on constitutional law and presidential power, Katz questions whether America’s founders truly intended the executive branch to wield an unrestricted power to dismiss officials.

Disputed Consensus

For decades, conventional wisdom suggested that the Founding Fathers embraced a unilateral “removal power.” Katz’s paper, however, challenges this assumption. According to the research, the notion of an absolute executive prerogative did not reflect unanimous agreement among early American lawmakers.

Historical Context

Citing debates from the founding era, Katz argues that the process of forming the executive branch was far more nuanced. While some framers favored a strong presidency, others expressed serious reservations about granting unchecked authority to remove members of the administration. Katz’s examination highlights this historical complexity, revealing that the concept of a unified stance on executive power may be oversimplified.

Implications for Modern Politics

Given the contemporary focus on the scope of presidential power, Katz’s findings raise questions about the constitutionality of long-standing beliefs. By tracing the origins of these assumptions back to the founders’ uncertain agreement, this research provides a fresh look at how political power was—and perhaps should be—allocated.

More from World

Maine Senate Hopeful Faces Past Controversy
by Politico
17 hours ago
2 mins read
Graham Platner tries to turn the page on his online comments
Dunbar Loses Vaccine Mandate Legal Battle
by Variety
17 hours ago
1 min read
‘9-1-1’ Actor Rockmond Dunbar Loses COVID Vaccine Lawsuit Against Disney
Grand Canyon Eases Water and Fire Rules
by Salt Lake City
17 hours ago
1 min read
Fire and water restrictions eased for Grand Canyon National Park
$600,000 Watch Stolen in Violent Irvine Robbery
by Ocregister
17 hours ago
1 min read
Man reports $600,000 watch stolen in Irvine robbery, says gun jammed during attack
Colleges Hesitant on Trump's Education Compact
by The Sun Chronicle
18 hours ago
2 mins read
With no takers yet, White House meets with colleges still weighing an agreement with Trump
Trump Accelerates Diplomacy After Gaza Ceasefire
by Newspressnow
18 hours ago
2 mins read
Trump seeks to build on momentum from Gaza deal in a busy diplomatic week
Trump Denies Monarchical Role Amid Protests
by The Independent
18 hours ago
2 mins read
Trump insists ‘I’m no King’ as thousands of ‘No Kings’ protests set to take place across the country
Trump Calls for Immediate Ukraine-Russia Ceasefire
by Caledonianrecord
19 hours ago
2 mins read
After Zelenskyy meeting, Trump calls on Ukraine and Russia to ‘stop where they are’ and end the war
Trump Commutes George Santos' Prison Sentence
by Kxan
19 hours ago
1 min read
Trump says he has commuted sentence of former US Rep. George Santos in federal fraud case
Trump urges Supreme Court to allow National Guard in Chicago
Israel's Qatar Strike Nearly Ruins Peace Talks
by Cbs News
19 hours ago
2 mins read
Witkoff, Kushner felt betrayed by Israel’s Qatar strike
Fans Criticize AI Graphics in PvZ Replanted
by Notebookcheck
19 hours ago
2 mins read
Plants vs. Zombies Replanted leaks, and players are horrified by its poor AI upscaling