In Whitestown, Indiana, an early-morning disturbance left one homeowner questioning how far stand-your-ground laws apply. As the clock neared 7 a.m., the incident evolved into a debate that challenges traditional notions of self-defense versus manslaughter.

A Walker County man was convicted last week of manslaughter for the 2022 shooting death of an Argo woman. The verdict marks the end of a case closely followed by residents of both communities.