Miss Manners: How do I get these demanding carolers to leave?

Key Takeaways:

• A worried reader is concerned about the demanding lyrics of “We Wish You a Merry Christmas.”
• Judith Martin’s response is couched in humor, reflecting the season’s festive spirit.
• The question focuses on politely asking carolers to leave without causing offense.
• Miss Manners reminds readers that kindness remains central to holiday gatherings.
• The column, featured on Cleveland, was published on December 24, 2025.

Carolers at the Door

Cleveland’s advice column recently spotlighted an unusual holiday conundrum: a reader who finds the lyrics of “We Wish You a Merry Christmas” uncomfortably forceful. In particular, the refrain about holding out for “some” pudding has the reader concerned that the carolers might not leave without a treat.

The Reader’s Concern

The letter to Miss Manners posed a simple question: “How do I get these demanding carolers to leave?” Though the holiday tune is traditionally good-spirited, the words can sound daunting to those worried about pushy guests. With the festive season in full swing, the reader sought a diplomatic way to maintain holiday cheer while also preserving household peace.

Judith Martin Responds

Advice columnist Judith Martin, known as Miss Manners, offered a characteristically witty response. She suggested acknowledging the humor in the song’s seemingly ominous line and meeting carolers with courtesy first. According to Martin’s seasonal humor, a warm but firm greeting—and perhaps a quick conversation—can gently redirect any performer clinging too closely to the tune’s demands.

A Seasonal Approach

Miss Manners’ column underscores that politeness remains the hallmark of any holiday gathering, even when the lyrics veer toward playful threats. By blending a gentle sense of humor with clear boundaries, households can navigate enthusiastic caroling without compromising on decorum. Judith Martin’s advice, published on December 24, 2025, through Cleveland’s platform, reminds readers that courtesy is a gift that never goes out of style.